PSAA Softball History
| Season | PSAA Softball Champions | Awards | Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Portledge School |
Regular Season MVP: Skylar McCann, Long Island Lutheran PSAA Championships MVP: Amanda Gleixner, Martin Luther Coach of the Year: Micki Curtain, Knox School |
Info |
| 2018 | Portledge School |
Regular Season MVP: Tali Schor, Schechter School of Long Island PSAA Championships MVP: Carly Kleinwaks, Portledge School Coach of the Year: Courtney Athens, Schechter School of Long Island |
Info |
| 2018 | Portledge School | Tali Schor, Schechter School of Long Island PSAA Championships MVP: Carly Kleinwaks, Portledge School |
Info |
| 2017 | Portledge School | East: Carly Kleinwaks, Portledge School West: Percy Hort, Léman Manhattan Prep PSAA Championships MVP: Leana Ruszack, Portledge School |
Info |
| 2016 | Solomon Schechter of Long Island | MVP: Shannon Motley; Staten Island Academy Playoff MVP: Talia Schor; Solomon Schechter of Long Island |
Info |
| 2015 | Staten Island Academy | West MVP: Shannon Motley; Staten Island Academy East MVP: Carly Kleinwaks; Portledge Playoff MVP: Shannon Motley - Staten Island Academy |
Info |
| 2007-14 | PSAA Softball Not Contested | ||
| 2006 | Long Island Lutheran | Maya Bassarath; Long Island Lutheran | |
| 2005 | Long Island Lutheran | Maya Bassarath; Long Island Lutheran | |
| 2004 | Long Island Lutheran | Tara Ciccione; Martin Luther | |
| 2003 | Long Island Lutheran | Christine Malaty; Long Island Lutheran | |
| 2002 | Staten Island Academy | Elizabeth Semmens; Berkeley Carroll | |
| 2001 | Long Island Lutheran | Krystal Dabrowski; Martin Luther | |
| 2000 | Berkeley Carroll | Amy Finerty; Martin Luther | |
| 1999 | Berkeley Carroll | Melissa Golden; Berkeley Carroll | |
| 1998 | Long Island Lutheran | Erin Dydland; Martin Luther | |
| 1997 | Martin Luther | Lauren Giacalone; Martin Luther | |
| 1996 | Martin Luther | Lauren Giacalone; Martin Luther | |
| 1995 | Long Island Lutheran | Jordana Schusteritsch; Martin Luther | |
| 1994 | Staten Island Academy | Bonnie Lee; Staten Island Academy | |
| 1993 | Martin Luther | Wendy Lobos; Martin Luther | |
| 1992 | Martin Luther | Tracie Smith; Staten Island Academy | |
| 1991 | Martin Luther | Michele Guzowski; Martin Luther | |
| 1990 | Martin Luther | Michele Guzowski; Martin Luther | |